Наслідки визнання правочину недійсним, Детальна інформація

12

E\x00F0\x00B3i aeainoi\x00F0iiiuei? \x00F0anoeoooe\x00B3?, OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie ia\x00F0aaeaa/a\x00BA ye iane\x00B3aeie iaae\x00B3eniino\x00B3 i\x00F0aai/eio a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy caeoe\x00B3a oa ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaee. Ca\x00B3aeii c ioieoii 2 no, 216 OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie o \x00F0ac\x00B3, yeui o ca'yceo \x00B3c a/eiaiiyi iaae\x00B3eniiai i\x00F0aai/eio ae\x00F0oa\x00B3e noi\x00F0ii\x00B3 aai o\x00F0ao\x00B3e inia\x00B3 caaaeaii caeoe\x00B3a oa ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaee, aiie i\x00B3aeeyaathoue a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiith aeiiith noi\x00F0iiith, i\x00F0e oeueiio caeii o aeayeeo aeiaaeeao iieeaaea\x00BA ia aeiio noi\x00F0iio iaia'ycie a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaoe ae\x00F0oa\x00B3e noi\x00F0ii\x00B3 caeoee o iiaea\x00B3eiiio \x00F0ici\x00B3\x00F0\x00B3 (noaoo\x00B3 230, 231 OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie).

Ca /eiiei OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie canoinoaaiiy ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaea, ye i\x00F0aaiai? aa\x00F0aio\x00B3? ii\x00F0ooaieo i\x00F0aa oa caeiiieo \x00B3ioa\x00F0an\x00B3a th\x00F0eaee/ieo in\x00B3a \x00BA oe\x00B3eaaei iiiaioii. Oae, /. 2 no. 227 OeE O\x00F0a?ie ia\x00F0aaeaa/a\x00BA i\x00F0aai ia a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaee inia\x00B3, yea aoea aaaaeaia \x00B3ioith th\x00F0eaee/iith iniaith a iiaio uiaei naiai i\x00F0aaa ia a/eiaiiy i\x00F0aai/eio, yeiai aiia ia iaea i\x00F0aaa a/eiyoe. Aeacai\x00B3 i\x00F0aai/eie iiaeooue aooe aeciai\x00B3 iaae\x00B3enieie eeoa o noaeiaiio ii\x00F0yaeeo ye ca iiciaii iiaeaoeiaeo i\x00F0aai\x00B3a aai i\x00F0ieo\x00F0i\x00F0a /e eiai canooiieea, oae \x00B3 ca\x00B3ioa\x00F0aniaaii? iniae., i\x00F0aaa oa \x00B3ioa\x00F0ane yei? ii\x00F0ooai\x00B3.

I\x00F0e caa\x00F0iaii\x00B3 a noae c iiciaii i\x00F0i a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaee iiceaa/ iiaeiai onoaiiaeoe, /e ae\x00B3yea a\x00B3aeiia\x00B3aeia caeiiiaeaa/a ii\x00F0ia, ui anoaiiaeth\x00BA eiai i\x00F0aai aeiaaaoe a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaee, o oie iiiaio, eiee eiio aoea caiiae\x00B3yia oaea oeiaea. Iaeii/anii, ea\x00F0oth/enue iinoaiiaith Ieaioio Aa\x00F0oiaiiai Noaeo Oe\x00F0a?ie „I\x00F0i noaeiao i\x00F0aeoeeo a ni\x00F0aaao i\x00F0i a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy ii\x00F0aeueii? (iaiaeiiai?) oeiaee" \x00B94 a\x00B3ae 31 aa\x00F0aciy 1995 \x00F0., iaia'ycie a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaee iioe\x00F0th\x00BAoueny e ia o\x00B3 i\x00F0aaia\x00B3aeiineie, ui aeieeee aei anooio a neeo caeiiiaeaa/iai aeoa, ui ia\x00F0aaeaa/a\x00BA i\x00F0aai ia a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy oaei? oeiaee. Aea inoaii\x00BA iieiaeaiiy iioe\x00F0th\x00BAoueny o\x00B3eueee ia o\x00B3 aeiaaeee, eiee iai\x00F0aaii\x00B3\x00F0i\x00B3 ae\x00B3? (aacae\x00B3yeuei\x00B3noue) ii/aeeny aei anooio a neeo caeiiiaeaa/iai aeoa, yeei anoaiiaeth\x00BAoueny a\x00B3aeiia\x00B3aeaeuei\x00B3noue ca a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaee, \x00B3 i\x00F0iaeiaaeothoueny i\x00B3ney anooio eiai a neeo.

A\x00F0aoiaoth/e aeuaaeeeaaeaia, ia aeeeth/aiee iio\x00B3e ni\x00F0aa i\x00F0i a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaee, caaaeaii? „iiaieeaith" oaiaeith, oeeaaeaiith ua aei 2004 \x00F0ieo. Aea ia aeaiiio aoai\x00B3 noaiiaeaiiy a\x00B3o/eciyiiai caeiiiaeaanoaa ana ae iaiao\x00B3aeii caa\x00F0iooe oaaao ia oie oaeo, ui \x00F0icaeyae ni\x00F0aa i\x00F0i eiiiainaoe\x00B3th ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaee iaaaci\x00B3aenoaaii aeeeeea\x00BA o noaeia\x00B3e i\x00F0aeoeoe\x00B3 iaai\x00B3 o\x00F0oaeiiu\x00B3. Oea iia'ycaii c oyi, ui aeaiee \x00B3inoeooo ciaoiaeeoueny a Oe\x00F0a?i\x00B3 eeoa ia aoai\x00B3 noaiiaeaiiy, a oiio iio\x00F0aao\x00BA ye cia/iiai caeiiiaeaa/iai aeiii\x00F0aoethaaiiy, oae \x00B3 iaaiiai /ano aeey oi\x00F0ioaaiiy noaei? i\x00F0aeoeee eiai canoinoaaiiy5.

Cacia/ai\x00B3 i\x00F0aaia\x00B3 iane\x00B3aeee iaae\x00B3eniino\x00B3 i\x00F0aai/eio o aeaeyae\x00B3 aeainoi\x00F0iiiuei? \x00F0anoeoooe\x00B3? oa a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy caeoe\x00B3a \x00B3 ii\x00F0aeueii? oeiaee canoiniaothoueny caaaeaee, yeui iieiaeaiiyie oeueiai caeiio uiaei ie\x00F0aieo aeae\x00B3a iaae\x00B3enieo i\x00F0aai/ei\x00B3a ia anoaiiaeai\x00B3 \x00B3io\x00B3 i\x00F0aaia\x00B3 iane\x00B3aeee.

5A. O\x00F0ieia Ae\x00F0\x00B3oaiiy nii\x00F0\x00B3a i\x00F0i aeciaiiy oaiae iaae\x00B3enieie /e iiciaaie iiaeaoeiaeo i\x00F0aai\x00B3a. I\x00F0aai Oe\x00F0a?ie, 2004, \x00B9 \x00B3o n. 60.

13

I\x00F0aaia\x00B3 iane\x00B3aeee iaae\x00B3eniino\x00B3 i\x00F0aai/ei\x00B3a, anoaiiaeaieo caeiiii, iiaeooue aooe ci\x00B3iai\x00B3 ca aeiiiaeai\x00B3noth noi\x00F0\x00B3i i\x00F0aai/eio, ca aeiyoeii i\x00B3e/aiieo i\x00F0aai/ei\x00B3a, i\x00F0aaia\x00B3 iane\x00B3aeee yeeo ia iiaeooue aooe ci\x00B3iai\x00B3 noi\x00F0iiaie (no. 216 OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie).

14

3. Iane\x00B3aeee iaaeiaea\x00F0aeaiiy oi\x00F0ie, noa'\x00BAeoiiai neeaaeo, aieaaeyaeaiiy, ci\x00B3noo i\x00F0aai/ei\x00B3a

Iaaeiaea\x00F0aeaiiy oi\x00F0ie i\x00F0aai/ei\x00B3a ca OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie aoaa\x00BA aeaio aeae\x00B3a - oea iaaeiaea\x00F0aeaiiy ienueiiai? oi\x00F0ie i\x00F0aai/ei\x00B3a (no. 218) \x00B3 iaaeiaea\x00F0aeaiiy aeiiae i\x00F0i iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueia iina\x00B3ae/aiiy i\x00F0aai/ei\x00B3a (noaoo\x00B3 219, 220).

OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie iaaieie i\x00F0aaiaeie caniaaie noeioeth\x00BA aeiaea\x00F0aeaiiy ienueiiai? oi\x00F0ie i\x00F0aai/ei\x00B3a. Aei oaeeo cania\x00B3a iaeaaeaoue iane\x00B3aeee iaaeiaea\x00F0aeaiiy noi\x00F0iiaie ienueiiai? oi\x00F0ie i\x00F0aai/eio. Noaooy 218 OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie aeoiaeeoue c oiai, ui iaaeiaea\x00F0aeaiiy noi\x00F0iiaie ienueiiai? oi\x00F0ie i\x00F0aai/eio ia aieeaa\x00BA ia eiai th\x00F0eaee/io neeo. Oaeee i\x00F0aai/ei \x00BA caeiiiei \x00B3 ae\x00B3eniei. \x00D0acii c oei noi\x00F0iie o i\x00F0aai/ei\x00B3 iaiaaeothoueny o aeai\x00F0\x00B3 aeieac\x00B3a aeey i\x00B3aeoaa\x00F0aeaeaiiy i\x00F0aai/eio o aeiaaeeo aeieeiaiiy nii\x00F0\x00B3a i\x00B3ae ieie. C oeueiai i\x00F0eaiaeo /. 2 no. 218 ia\x00F0aaeaa/a\x00BA, ui o \x00F0ac\x00B3 caia\x00F0a/aiiy iaei\x00B3\x00BAth \x00B3c noi\x00F0\x00B3i iayaiino\x00B3 i\x00F0aai/eio aai inii\x00F0thaaiiy ie\x00F0aieo eiai /anoei noi\x00F0iie ia iathoue i\x00F0aaa iineeaoeny ia na\x00B3ae/aiiy na\x00B3aee\x00B3a. Iayai\x00B3noue naiiai i\x00F0aai/eio, eiai ci\x00B3no iiaeooue aeiaiaeeoeny ienueiiaeie aeieacaie aai ca aeiiiiiaith cania\x00B3a aoae\x00B3i- oa a\x00B3aeaicaieno.

Iaaeiaea\x00F0aeaiiiy ienueiiai? oi\x00F0ie i\x00F0aai/eio ni\x00F0e/eith\x00BA eiai iaae\x00B3eni\x00B3noue eeoa o aeiaaeeao, eiee oaeee iane\x00B3aeie i\x00F0yii cacia/aiee o caeii\x00B3.

I\x00F0aai/eie, ye\x00B3 a/eiai\x00B3 ienueiiai, iio\x00F0aaothoue iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueiiai iina\x00B3ae/aiiy eeoa o aeiaaeeao, ia\x00F0aaeaa/aieo caeiiii. Iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueia iina\x00B3ae/aiiy i\x00F0aai/eio cae\x00B3enith\x00BAoueny iioa\x00F0\x00B3onii aai \x00B3ioith iinaaeiaith iniaith, yea a\x00B3aeiia\x00B3aeii aei caeiio ia\x00BA i\x00F0aai ia a/eiaiiy oaei? iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueii? ae\x00B3?, oeyoii a/eiaiiy ia aeieoiaio\x00B3, ia yeiio aeeeaaeaii oaeno i\x00F0aai/eio, iina\x00B3ae/oaaeueiiai iaieno (no. 209 OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie).

*eiiee oeea\x00B3eueiee eiaeaen ia\x00F0aaeaa/a\x00BA iane\x00B3aeee iaaeiaea\x00F0aeaiiy aeiia caeiio i\x00F0i iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueia iina\x00B3ae/aiiy iaeiinoi\x00F0iiiueiai i\x00F0aai/eio \x00B3 aeiaiai\x00F0o (noaoo\x00B3 219, 220). Iaaeiaea\x00F0aeaiiy aeiiae caeiio i\x00F0i iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueia iina\x00B3ae/aiiy iaeiinoi\x00F0iiiueai i\x00F0aai/eio ia\x00BA iane\x00B3aeeii eiai iaae\x00B3eni\x00B3noue. OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie aeiionea\x00BA aeiyoie c oeueiai i\x00F0aaeea. Noae iiaea aeciaoe oaeee i\x00F0aai/ei ae\x00B3eniei, yeui aoaea anoaiiaeaii, ui a\x00B3i a\x00B3aeiia\x00B3aea\x00BA ni\x00F0aaaei\x00B3e aie\x00B3 iniae, yea eiai a/eieea, a iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueiiio iina\x00B3ae/aiith i\x00F0aai/eio ia\x00F0aoeiaeaeaea ianoaaeia, yea ia caeaaeaea a\x00B3ae ?? aie\x00B3.

Iaaeiaea\x00F0aeaiiy noi\x00F0iiaie aeiiae caeiio i\x00F0i iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueia iina\x00B3ae/aiiy aeiaiai\x00F0o oaeiae ia\x00BA iane\x00B3aeeii eiai iaae\x00B3eni\x00B3noue. C oeueiai i\x00F0aaeea oaeiae ia\x00F0aaeaa/ai\x00B3 aeiyoee.

sseui noi\x00F0iie aeiiiaeeeny uiaei on\x00B3o \x00B3noioieo oiia aeiaiai\x00F0o, ui i\x00B3aeoaa\x00F0aeaeothoueny ienueiiaeie aeieacaie, \x00B3 a\x00B3aeaoeiny iiaia aai /anoeiaa aeeiiaiiy aeiaiai\x00F0o, aea iaeia \x00B3c noi\x00F0\x00B3i ooeey\x00BAoueny a\x00B3ae eiai iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueiiai iina\x00B3ae/aiiy, noae iiaea aeciaoe oaeee aeiaia\x00B3\x00F0 ae\x00B3eniei. O oeueiio \x00F0ac\x00B3 ianooiia iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueia ioi\x00F0ieaiiy ia iio\x00F0\x00B3aia.

OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie noa\x00BA ia caoeno ii\x00F0yaeiiai \x00B3 aeia\x00F0inia\x00B3niiai o/anieea i\x00F0aai/eio \x00B3 ni\x00F0ey\x00BA cae\x00B3eniaiith eiai iaeiiaeo \x00B3ioa\x00F0an\x00B3a. Noae aai ainiiaea\x00F0nueeee noae, anoaiiaeaoe iaae\x00B3eni\x00B3noue i\x00F0aai/eio aiane\x00B3aeie

15

ii\x00F0ooaiiy iioa\x00F0\x00B3aeueii? oi\x00F0ie, iiaa\x00F0oa\x00BA noi\x00F0iie o iiia\x00F0aaei\x00B3e iaeiiaee noai, oiaoi canoiniao\x00BA aeainoi\x00F0iiith \x00F0anoeoooe\x00B3th.

Ine\x00B3eueee i\x00F0aai/ei \x00BA aieueiaei aeoii, ni\x00F0yiiaaiei ia aeinyaiaiiy i\x00F0aaiaiai \x00F0acoeueoaoo, oi e oeeaaeaoe eiai iiaeooue eeoa iniae, ye\x00B3 aieiae\x00B3thoue o oiio /e \x00B3ioiio ianyc\x00B3 ae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoi\x00B3noth, oiaoi aiey yeeo oa\x00F0aeoa\x00F0eco\x00BAoueny aeinoaoiuei ineo\x00B3/iith c\x00F0\x00B3e\x00B3noth. Oeea\x00B3eueiee eiaeaen ia\x00F0aaeaa/a\x00BA (noaoo\x00B3 31, 39), ui a\x00B3ae \x00B3iai\x00B3 in\x00B3a, aeciaieo iaae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoieie, a oaeiae a\x00B3ae \x00B3iai\x00B3 iaeie\x00B3oi\x00B3o aei 14 \x00F0ie\x00B3a oeeaaeathoue i\x00F0aai/eie aaoueee, oneiiaeoae\x00B3, ii\x00B3eoie. O\x00B3ce/i\x00B3 iniae o a\x00B3oe\x00B3 a\x00B3ae 14 aei 18 \x00F0ie\x00B3a, ui iathoue iaiiaio ae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoi\x00B3noue, \x00B3 iaiaaeaii ae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoi\x00B3 aiane\x00B3aeie aaeeaaiiy nie\x00F0oieie iaiiyie /e ia\x00F0eioe/ieie caniaaie iiaeooue oeeaaeaoe i\x00F0aai/eie a\x00B3aeiia\x00B3aeii ca caiaeith aaouee\x00B3a, oneiiaeoae\x00B3a oa i\x00B3eeoaaeueiee\x00B3a, ca aeiyoeii ae\x00F0\x00B3aieo iiaooiaeo oaiae.

A/eiaiiy i\x00F0aai/ei\x00B3a iaae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoieie iniaaie, a oaeiae iaeie\x00B3oi\x00B3ie aei 14 \x00F0ie\x00B3a, iniaaie ui iathoue iaiiaio /e iaiaaeaio ae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoi\x00B3noue, ca iaaeaie ?o ae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoiino\x00B3, coiiaeth\x00BA ?o iaae\x00B3eni\x00B3noue.

I\x00F0aaiaei iane\x00B3aeeii a/eiaiiy i\x00F0aai/eio iaeie\x00B3oi\x00B3i aei 14 \x00F0ie\x00B3a, ca iaaeaie eiai ae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoiino\x00B3 oa iaae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoiith iniaith \x00BA (noaoo\x00B3 222, 226 OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie) iiiiaeaiiy noi\x00F0\x00B3i o iiia\x00F0aaeiueiio iaeiiaiio noai\x00B3, a ca iaiiaeeeaino\x00B3 oaeiai iiiiaeaiiy eiaeia c\x00B3 noi\x00F0\x00B3i ia\x00BA a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaoe \x00B3io\x00B3e noi\x00F0iie aa\x00F0o\x00B3noue iaea\x00F0aeaiiai o a\x00F0ioao ca oe\x00B3iaie, ui \x00B3niothoue ia iiiaio a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy.

OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie ia\x00F0aaeaa/a\x00BA, ui ae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoia noi\x00F0iia ciaia'ycaia oaeiae a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaoe caeoee, caaaeai\x00B3 oeeaaeaiiyi iaae\x00B3eniiai i\x00F0aai/eio iaeie\x00B3oi\x00B3e inia\x00B3 aei 14 \x00F0ie\x00B3a, yeui o iiiaio a/eiaiy i\x00F0aai/eio aiia ciaea aai iiaea ciaoe i\x00F0i a\x00B3e \x00B3ioi? noi\x00F0iie (no. 222).

Aeiaeaoeiaee iaia'ycie ae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoii? iniae a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaoe caeoee iioa\x00F0i\x00B3e\x00B3e iaae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoi\x00B3e inia\x00B3 ia \x00BA i\x00F0aaiaei iane\x00B3aeeii a/eiaiiy i\x00F0aai/eio iaae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoiith iniaith ca /eiiei eiaeaenii (no. 226), ia a\x00B3aei\x00B3io a\x00B3ae OeE O\x00D0N\x00D0 1963\x00F0.(no.51).

Iiaee OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie ia\x00F0aaeaa/a\x00BA i\x00F0aaia\x00B3 iane\x00B3aeee a/eiaiiy i\x00F0aai/eio, yeui iaiia noi\x00F0iiaie i\x00F0aai/eio \x00BA iaeie\x00B3oi\x00B3: o \x00F0ac\x00B3 eiai iaae\x00B3eniino\x00B3 canoiniao\x00BAoueny aeainoi\x00F0iiiy \x00F0anoeoooe\x00B3y. O \x00F0ac\x00B3 iaiiaeeeaino\x00B3 iiaa\x00F0iooe iaeii a iaoo\x00F0\x00B3 eiai aa\x00F0o\x00B3noue a\x00B3aeoeiaeiaothoue aaoueee (oneiiaeoae\x00B3) /e ii\x00B3eoi, yeui aoaea anoaiiaeaii, ui a/eiaiith i\x00F0aai/eio aai ao\x00F0ao\x00B3 iaeia, yea aoei i\x00F0aaeiaoii i\x00F0aai/eio, ni\x00F0eyea ?oiy aeiia iiaaae\x00B3iea. Oaeiae \x00BA iiaei i\x00F0aaeei i\x00F0i i\x00F0aaia\x00B3 iane\x00B3aeee iaae\x00B3eniino\x00B3 i\x00F0aai/eio, oeeaaeaiiai iaeie\x00B3oi\x00B3i c iniaith a\x00B3eii a\x00B3ae 14 aei 18 \x00F0ie\x00B3a. O \x00F0ac\x00B3 iaae\x00B3eniino\x00B3 oaeiai i\x00F0aai/eio canoiniao\x00BAoueny aeainoi\x00F0iiiy \x00F0anoeoooe\x00B3y. Ca iaiiaeeeaino\x00B3 iiaa\x00F0iooe iaeii a iaoo\x00F0\x00B3 a\x00B3aeoeiaeiao\x00BAoueny eiai aa\x00F0o\x00B3noue. sseui o iaiiaiie\x00B3oiueiai iaia\x00BA eioo\x00B3a, iaiao\x00B3aeieo aeey a\x00B3aeoeiaeoaaiiy, ?o aeieaoo cae\x00B3eniththoue aaoueee (oneiiaeoae\x00B3), i\x00B3eeoaaeueieee iaiiaiie\x00B3oiueiai ca oiiae, ui aiie nai\x00BAth aeiiith iiaaae\x00B3ieith ni\x00F0eyee a/eiaiith i\x00F0aai/eio aai ao\x00F0ao\x00B3 iaeia, yea aoei i\x00F0aaeiaoii i\x00F0aai/eio.

O /eiiiio OeE Oe\x00F0a?ie iaeiei c i\x00F0aaiaeo iane\x00B3aee\x00B3a ia a\x00B3aei\x00B3io a\x00B3ae OeE O\x00D0N\x00D0 1963 \x00F0. iaeiei c i\x00F0aaiaeo iane\x00B3aee\x00B3a iaae\x00B3eniino\x00B3 i\x00F0aai/io, a/eiaiiai iaae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoiith iniaith, \x00BA iaia'ycie ae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoii? noi\x00F0iie eiiiainoaaoe

16

ii\x00B3eoiia\x00B3 iaae\x00B3\x00BAcaeaoii? iniae ii\x00F0aeueio oeiaeo, yeui aoaea anoaiiaeaii, ui aiia ciaea i\x00F0i ineo\x00B3/io oai\x00F0iao aai iaaeioinoai \x00B3ioi? noi\x00F0iie aai iiaea i\x00F0eioneaoe oaeee noai iniae.